Averroes-Database


A Service of the
Thomas-Institut, Köln















[5]

Middle Commentary on the Prior Analytics

Title: TalÌÐÒ kitÁb al-qiyÁs

(E) Mentioned in the Arabic bibliographies only under a general heading, designating all the Middle Commentaries on the Organon: TalÌÐÒ kitÁb ÞArisÔÙ fÐ l-manÔiq (B20, M29)

Cf. CCAA § 13; A 22f, 65f; HÜb § 19.

Manuscripts:

a) arab.:
Dublin, Chester Beatty 3769, ff. 60r-203v
Cairo, DÁr al-kutub wa-l-wa×ÁÞiq al-qaumÐya, 4076, Ms. 9 ManÔiq (dat. 1763), ff. 57v-173r
Firenze, Bibl. Laurentiana, Ms. Orient. CLXXX, 54, ff. 22r-65r
Leiden, University Library, Ms. Orient. 1691 (olim 2073), ff. 23r-75v
Teheran, DÁnišgÁh, MiškÁt 375, ff. 37r-124v
Teheran, MaÊlis-i ŠÙrÁ-i MillÐ 5496, ff. 50r-166r
Teheran, KitÁbÌÁna-i MillÐ-i Malik 3980, ff. 36r-110v
Manchester, John Rylands Univ. Lib., Arabic Ms. 374 [349], ff. 1r-36r (incomplete)

b) hebr.:
To be completed

c) lat.:
William of Luna:
Roma, Bibl. Apost. Vat., Urbinates lat. 221, ff. 118r-142v (
AL 1814)

Editions:

a) arab.:

• Lasinio, Fausto. "Studii sopra Averroe, V". Annuario della Società Italiana per gli Studi Orientali 2 (1873): 234-267. {11}
○ Contains on pp. 242-259 the Arabic (from Ms. Firenze) and Hebrew text of chapter 1.

• Ibn Rušd. TalÌÐÒ manÔiq ÞArisÔÙ / [Parallel title:] Averroès. Paraphrase de la logique d'Aristote. TaÎqÐq ÉirÁr ÉihÁmÐ [= Gérard Jéhamy]. MuÊallad 1-3 (ManšÙrÁt al-ÊÁmiÝa al-lubnÁnÐya: qism al-dirÁsÁt al-falsafÐya wa-l-ÞiÊtimÁÝÐya 12). BairÙt, 1982. [Reprinted: BairÙt, 1992]. {9}
○ Vol. 1, pp. 135-366 "TalÌÐÒ kitÁb ÞAnÁlÙÔÐqÐ al-Þawwal Þau kitÁb al-qiyÁs".

• Ibn Rušd. TalÌÐÒ kitÁb al-qiyÁs / [Parallel title:] Averrois Cordubensis [Commentarium medium] in Aristotelis Priorum analiticorum libros. ÍaqqaqahÙ l-marÎÙm MaÎmÙd QÁsim, rÁÊaÝahÙ wa-ÞakmalahÙ wa-qaddama lahÙ wa-Ýallaqa Ýalaihi Charles Butterworth, ÞAÎmad ÝAbd al-MaÊÐd al-HarÐdÐ (CCAA: Versio Arabica Vol. I, a, 4). Cairo, 1983. {16}

• Ibn Rušd. TalÌÐÒ al-qiyÁs li-ÞArisÔÙ. ÍaqqaqahÙ wa-Ýallaqa Ýalaihi wa-qaddama lahÙ ÝAbd al-RaÎmÁn BadawÐ. Kuwait, 1988. {17}

b) hebr.:

• Lasinio, Fausto. "Studii sopra Averroe, V". Annuario della Società Italiana per gli Studi Orientali 2 (1873): 234-267. {11}
○ Contains on pp. 242-259 the Arabic (from Ms. Firenze) and Hebrew text of chapter 1.

c) lat.:

• Aristotelis Priorum Resolutorium [libri], cum Averrois Cordubensis media Expositione. Ioanne Francisco Burana Veronensi interprete (Aristotelis Opera cum Averrois Commentariis, Venetiis: apud Junctas, 1562 [reprinted: Frankfurt a.M. 1962], Vol. 1, part 1, ff. 1r-168v [second, independently numbered set of pages]). {0}
○ For further editions of Burana's translation see Cranz: Venetiis: apud Iuntas, 1550/1552 (108.193); Venetiis: Cominus de Tridino Montisferrati, 1560 (108.423); Venetiis: Iuntae, 1575 (108.599).
William of Luna's translation is contained in the following editions: Venetiis: Paganinus de Paganinis/Iohannes et Gregorius de Gregoriis, 1501 (Cranz 107.693); Venetiis: Bonetus Locatellus, 1508 (107.753a); Venetiis: Octavianus Scotus, 1516 (107.838); Venetiis: Papie: Iacobus Paucidrapius de Burgofranco, 1520/21 (107.870=107.876B); Lugduni: Scipio de Gabiano, 1530 (107.921).

Translations:

Supercommentaries:

Literature:

Cf. the bibliography, especially: (57) Elamrani-Jamal, Abdelali. "Ibn Rušd et les Premiers Analytiques d'Aristote. Aperçu sur un problème de syllogistique modale"...; (66) Harvey, Steven. "Averroes' Use of Examples in his Middle Commentary on the Prior Analytics and Some Remarks on his Role as Commentator"...




Previous Averrois Opera Next




David Wirmer, Thomas-Institut, Cologne
Last updated: 02/08/2005